About Contact Ordering & Shipping Info Store-to-Car Pickup

2010-2012 Penn Avenue

Pittsburgh, PA 15222

64 matches for 'cheddar cheese'

  • Products in CHEESE Domestic/Artisan:

    • Bellavitano Merlot : Lb - Wisconsin Bellavitano cheese features a rich and creamy texture with a taste of an aged, premium Wisconsin Cheddar cheese balanced by a full-flavored Parmesan.
      Lb Pc
    • Carolina Reaper:Troyer Lb - HOT!
      A rich and creamy cheddar blended with Caralina Reaper Chili Peppers, which have a mean heat of between 1.4 million and 2.2 million Scoville heat units.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar 20 Yr White - OUT OF STOCK
      Wisconsin-The older the cheese the sharper the flavor, with deep caramel notes.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar 4-Alarm Lb - 4 Alarm Cheddar is a unique blend of Chipotle Peppers, Chili Peppers, Jalapeno Peppers and Ghost Pepper.
      It has lots of flavor with a sneaky burn at the end.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar 5Yr White: Lb - This Wisconsin Cheddar does not contain color additives and has been aged for 5 Years, giving it an incredible sharp flavor with just the right amount of bite!
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Black Diamond: Lb - Made from the freshest non-pasteurized Cow's milk, which allow the cheese to be aged up to 2 years to attain it's exceptional taste and texture.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Habanero & Jalapeno Lb. - Pasteurized Aged New York Cheddar with Habanero, Jalapeno and Cayenne Peppers.
      Make a grilled cheese sandwich, it will leave you dancin' in a burning ring of fire!
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Horseradish: Lb. - The biting pungency of horseradish is blended perfectly with the smooth, youthful cheddar taste.
      For an extra zing, pile it high on a baked potato or slice it for grilled meats or gourmet Italian sandwiches.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Mild: New York Lb - Premium naturally aged mild cheddar cheese has a mild taste and buttery texture, this cheese is sure to be a favorite among kids and adults alike!
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Praire Breeze :Lb - Made with vegetable rennet and no color added, this cheese is creamy yet crumbly with an added crunch from the calcium that develops during the aging process.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar SUPER Sharp:Hoffman Lb - Hoffmans SUPER Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a high-quality specialty cheese.
      Ideal for creating cheese snacks, mac and cheese or grilled cheese sandwiches.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Shrp Orange:New York Lb - McCadam Brand
      One of the most popular cheddars, very creamy, not overly sharp.
      Great for snacking or melting.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Shrp White:New York Lb. - McCadam Brand
      One of the most popular cheddars, very creamy, not overly sharp.
      Great for snacking or melting.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar X-Sharp: Cabot Lb. - It never tastes the same from one batch to the next, but in the best way possible.
      Try it for yourself on a cracker or on rustic Italian white bread to see what all the fuss is about!
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar X-Sharp: Tillamook Lb - Naturally aged for over two years which makes this cheese strikingly mature, award-winning flavor.
      A little dry and crumbly, but it's a perfect companion to fruit dishes and wine.
      Lb Pc
    • Colby Longhorn : Lb - Some people compare Colby to cheddar, they taste very different.
      Cheddar can be sharp or mild, but Colby cheese is always mild.
      This is because Colby is softer than cheddar, with a more open texture.
      Lb Pc
    • Pepperoni Cheese : Hormel 5LB - NOT SLICED-5Lb Block
      Hormel Brand-Gluten/Free-Pasteurized process cheddar and pepperoni cheese product.
    • Pepperoni Cheese: Hormel Lb - NOT SLICED-Hormel Brand-Gluten/Free-Pasteurized process cheddar and pepperoni cheese product.
      Lb Pc
    • Robin Lb - OUT OF STOCK
      The Robin is a classic, handcrafted Wisconsin Colby-style cow's milk cheese made by Master Cheese Makers Deer Creek that will become your new go-to cheddar with the first bite.
      Lb Pc
    • Scorpion Cheddar : Troyer Lb - Creamy Cheddar blended with Scorpion Chili Peppers, which have a mean heat of more than 1.2 million scoville heat units.
      Ingredients: Pasteurized milk, cultures, salt, less than 1% enzymes, annatto (color), ground Scorpion Chili Peppers.
      Lb Pc

  • Products in CHEESE Samplers:

  • Products in CHEESE English :

    • Applewood: 1/2 Wheel - Manufactured by Norseland Limited
      Formerly Ilchester Cheese Company in Somerset, England.
      Also goes by the name of Applewood smoked cheddar.
      1/2 Wheel weighs 3.3Lb
    • Applewood: Lb - Manufactured by Norseland Limited
      Formerly Ilchester Cheese Company in Somerset, England.
      Also goes by the name of Applewood smoked cheddar.
      This dense semi-hard cheese was first invented in 1965 in Somerset, England.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Welsh: Wales Lb. - A pasteurized cow's milk with a medium texture.
      Characteristics: light yellow in color with a savoury, yet slightly sweet taste.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar: Red Leicester Lb. - A cow's milk cheese with a rich, mild flavor and a flaky texture.
      Red Leicester Cheese is excellent with fruit and a wonderful Stout.
      Leicester is made in a similar fashion to cheddar and comes covered in a hard, dry, bright orange rind.
      Lb Pc
    • Wensleydale Smoked Cheddar: LB - Handcrafted cheese that's naturally smoked over oak chips for 18 hours, creating a cheese with a subtle smoked flavour.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar 5 Counties: Lb Pc - NOT AVAILABLE
      Made by combining five English kinds of cheese namely, Cheddar, Cheshire, Derby, Double Gloucester and Red Leicester.
      The alternating layers of yellow, orange and white makes this cheese visually stunning on a cheese platter.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar W/Onions Pickwick: Lb - OUT OF STOCK
      A Smooth, buttery Double Gloucester cheese infused with onion and chives. Belton Farm's Double Gloucester Onion and Chive recipe has been handed down over generations.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar W/Onions Pickwick:Wheel - OUT OF STOCK
      New size 5Lb Wheel-Coombe Castle-Pickwick
      Deliciously sweet and sharp caramelized onions are blended with a mild cheddar to create this savoury blend-the ultimate mix of cheese and onion.

  • Products in CHEESE Ireland :

    • Cheddar Cahill Porter Lb. - Made from pasteurized cow's milk and is considered a vegetarian cheese because a vegetable rennet is used through the cheese.
      It goes without saying that a dark beer is an ideal pairing.
      Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Cahill Whiskey Lb. - A pasteurized sheep and cow's milk, infused with the robust flavor of whiskey, this creamy Aged Cheddar has unique undertones of the smooth, woody and nutty taste of pure Irish Whiskey. Lb Pc
    • Cheddar Dubliner Lb. - Deriving its flavors from Cheddar and Parmigiano Reggiano, Irish Dubliner is a sweet, crumbly cheese that goes well with red wines & Irish beers!
      Lb Pc

  • Products in Sandwich Rings | Appetizer Trays:

    • American Sandwich Ring - IN-STORE PICK UP ONLY!
      Please request pick up to be the day of your function.
      The bread will get soggy if it sits too long
      American White Bread Sandwich Ring
    • NOBlack/Gold American Ring - NOT AVAILABLE!
    • Whole Wedge Cheese/Fruit Tray - IN-STORE PICK UP ONLY!
      4Lb's of different cheeses with fruit on a 12in tray.
      Includes:1Lb Wedge, 5 Counties Cheddar

      1Lb Wedge, D'Affinois

      1Lb Wedge, Cacio De Roma

      1Lb Wedge, Fontinella

      Garnished with In-season fruit.

  • Products in CLUB Cheese of the Month :

    • Cheddar Cheese Sampler - You will receive a 1/2Lb each of the following:
      Includes: Wisconsin 5 Year-Tillamook-Kerry Gold-Barber's
    • Most Popular Cheese Sampler - You will receive a 1/2Lb each of the following:
      Includes: Beemster Extra Aged-Piave D.O.C.-Auricchio Provolone-Welsh Cheddar

  • Products in Deli Cheese:

    • *Cheese Garlic Chdr: Troyer LB - SLICED-Just the right amount of garlic.
      Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, water, sodium phosphate, garlic powder, salt, sorbic acid (preservative), parsley flakes.
      Lb Sliced Thin
    • *Cheese Pepperoni: Lb. - SLICED-Hormel Brand-Gluten/Free
      Pasteurized process cheddar and pepperoni cheese product.
      Lb Sliced

  • Products in Gift Boxes/One Click Food Packages:

    • Isaly's & Pierogi Combo - Halftime Gift Box!
      Items-Shipment includes:
      Two-1Lb packages of Isaly's Chipped Chopped Ham
      1-16oz Jar Isaly's BBQ Sauce
      1-Dozen of Pierogi Plus Potato & Cheddar Cheese Pierogies.

  • Products in Faves Pierogies Plus:

    • Cheese and Potato Pierogies - The plumpist potato and cheddar cheese pierogi in Pittsburgh!
      Sold by the dozen.
      More info at https://pierogiesplus.com/about/

  • Products in Mustard:

    • Roland: Dijon Extra Strong - Its rich flavor and smooth, non-gritty texture will have you believing that you too are in Europe, enjoying this mustard.
      A Product of France.
      7oz.

  • Products in G/F Soup Mix :

  • Products in CHEESE Misc from Around The World:

    • Mexico: Queso Chihuahua Lb. - The melting cheese you need for homemade quesadillas, burritos, and any other Mexican treats.
      A perfect dipping cheese, as well!
      Lb Pc

  • Products in CHEESE French :

    • Mimolette 1 Year Lb. - Resembles a cantalope, and aged in a cave for 12 months.
      Mimolette has a subtle fruity and mellow nutty flavor.
      This cheese goes great with red wine or a fine ale.
      Lb Pc

  • Products in CHEESE Swiss :

    • Emmentaler Swiss Lb. - Emmentaler cheese is partially skimmed, low sodium-50mg per oz, unpasteurized cow's milk.
      It is relatively firm and has a natural rind.
      It is typically yellowish-tan in color and has a mild, nutty, fruity flavor. Lb Pc

Copyright © PENNSYLVANIA MACARONI COMPANY, PITTSBURGH, PA. Accessibility Statement