BRINGING ITALY
TO YOUR TABLE

Four Generations.
One Legendary Store.

Behind Pittsburgh's iconic red doors, the Sunseri family has hand-selected over 5,000 Italian specialty products for more than a century—now shipped to your door.

Family-Owned Since 1902

Direct Italian Imports

5,000+ Products

OUR HERITAGE

Four Generations
of Italian Excellence

From a small grocery to an iconic Pittsburgh institution.

The Sunseri family story.

1902

The Beginning

Salvatore, Augustino and Michelino Sunseri opened a small Italian grocery in Pittsburgh's Strip District, importing pasta, olive oil, and cheeses from Sicily.

1940s

Growing Roots

The second generation expands the store, becoming the go-to destination for Pittsburgh's Italian community and beyond.

1980s

Cheese Empire

Penn Mac becomes nationally known for its legendary cheese selection — over 400 varieties from around the world.

Today

Four Generations Strong

Still family-owned, now shipping nationwide. The same passion, the same quality, the same red doors on Penn Avenue.

Shop by Category

View All Categories
Italian Cheese
Italian Cheese
Italian Cheese
→
Pasta
Pasta
Pasta
→
Italian Olive Oil
Italian Olive Oil
Italian Olive Oil
→
Sliced Deli
Sliced Deli
Sliced Deli
→

Staff Picks

Staff Picks

Hand-selected favorites from our family to yours

As do Mar - Tuna

As do Mar

As do Mar - Tuna

$8.99
Sale price  $8.99 Regular price 

 · 3.5–7oz

Alta Badia - lb

Alta Badia

Alta Badia - lb

$17.99
Sale price  $17.99 Regular price 

 

Auricchio - Provolone - lb

Auricchio

Auricchio - Provolone - lb

$18.99
Sale price  $18.99 Regular price 

 

Bufala Quadrello - lb

Bufala Quadrello - lb

$27.99
Sale price  $27.99 Regular price 

 

Slideshow

“

I want people to have Penn Mac in their lives. I want to get back to personal contact. No third parties. I want customers to communicate with us.

BILL SUNSERI

Third-generation co-owner

120+

Years in Business

5,000+

Specialty Products

400+

Varieties of Cheese

48

States Served