All Cheese
223 products
Allegheny Mountain Cheese
1 products
Amaretti
3 products
Anchovies
10 products
Artichokes
6 products
Assorted Cheese From Around The World
6 products
Auricchio
4 products
Baci
2 products
Baking
75 products
Baking Extracts
33 products
Baking Fillings & Pastes
6 products
Baking Tools & Makers
7 products
Balsamic Vinegar
10 products
Barbeque Rubs
7 products
Beans
8 products
Beverage Effervescents
3 products
Beverages
10 products
Beverages La Dolce Vita
1 products
Biscotti
3 products
Biscotti & Pizzelles
21 products
OUR HERITAGE
The cheese counter that built our reputation
Step into the Strip District store and the cheese counter is the first thing you notice — a glass case running the length of the back wall, stacked with wheels and wedges from a dozen countries. Our cheesemongers have been working that counter for decades, slicing to order, walking customers through what's new on the wheel that week.
Every morning, fresh mozzarella is pulled by hand in the back kitchen and brought out warm. The Parmigiano comes direct from the same Emilia-Romagna families our buyers have known for generations. Nothing about how we run that counter has changed — and that's the point.
Staff Picks
What our cheesemongers are reaching for this week
How to Build a Cheese Board
Start with three styles
A hard aged, a soft bloomy, and a blue. Three texturescover every palate at the table without overwhelming theboard.
Add something fresh
Balance the aged cheeses with a ball of our hand-pulledmozzarella or a knob of fresh ricotta cut that morning.
Pair with bread and honey
Crusty Italian loaves, a drizzle of chestnut honey, a fewsalumi slices. Simple accompaniments that let the cheeselead.
About Our Cheese Selection
The Pennsylvania Macaroni Company cheese counter has been part of the Strip District since 1902 — first as a small case beside the pasta wall, then as the long glass counter that anchors the back of the store today. Generations of Pittsburgh families have brought their holidays through this counter, and the rhythm of it hasn't changed.
We carry Italian classics — Parmigiano Reggiano, Pecorino Romano, Gorgonzola, Taleggio — alongside French imports from Normandy and the Loire, aged English cheddars, Spanish Manchego, and the fresh mozzarella our kitchen pulls every morning. The blue cheese case alone runs from gentle dolce to the punchiest Stilton on the shelf.
Everything is cut to order. Tell our cheesemongers what you're cooking, who you're feeding, what you tried last week — they'll point you to the wheel that's eating best right now. That conversation is the counter. It's why people drive in from three states to shop here.